Firestop Engineering Judgments Are Not As-Built Drawings

June 30, 2026

Engineering Judgments, often called EJs or Technical Evaluations, play an important role in the firestop industry. They help address unique field conditions where a tested and listed firestop system may not match the exact project condition.

But there is a growing concern in the industry: Engineering Judgments are increasingly being requested, reviewed, and revised as though they are as-built drawings, coordination drawings, or complete construction documents.

That is not their intended purpose.

The International Firestop Council has released a position statement to clarify the proper role, scope, and expectations for firestop Engineering Judgments.

What an Engineering Judgment Is

A firestop Engineering Judgment is a technical evaluation based on tested systems, engineering principles, and applicable guidance. It is intended to address specific firestop performance considerations and provide schematic, representative details.

In other words, an EJ should identify the critical information needed to achieve the stated firestop system performance. It should not attempt to document every surrounding construction condition.

What an Engineering Judgment Is Not

Engineering Judgments are not intended to serve as:

  • As-built drawings
  • Coordination drawings
  • Complete construction documents
  • Code compliance evaluations for surrounding construction
  • A substitute for the Registered Design Professional’s project responsibilities

For example, an EJ may show certain surrounding elements for context, but the EJ issuer is not typically determining whether those surrounding elements comply with all applicable code requirements. Items such as the rating of the assembly, damper requirements, the need for a T-rating, or the classification of a wall as a fire barrier, fire partition, smoke barrier, or fire wall remain the responsibility of the project design professional.

Why Too Much Detail Can Create Problems

Adding unnecessary detail to an Engineering Judgment does not necessarily improve the document. In fact, it can create several negative consequences.

When EJs are pushed toward as-built or coordination drawings, it can increase costs, delay approvals, create unnecessary revision cycles, and cause confusion for contractors, designers, AHJs, and special inspectors.

It may also create the appearance that the EJ issuer evaluated or accepted conditions that were never actually reviewed for firestop performance.

That is a problem for the entire project team.

When Additional Detail Is Appropriate

Additional detail may be appropriate when the information materially impacts firestop performance. This may include items such as opening size, joint width, substrate type, assembly thickness, penetrant characteristics, movement behavior, or other conditions that directly affect firestop system selection and performance.

However, details that do not materially affect firestop performance should generally be avoided.

The goal is not to make the EJ look more complete as a drawing. The goal is to make the EJ technically clear, defensible, and focused on the firestop condition being evaluated.

The Bottom Line

Engineering Judgments should remain engineering tools.

They should communicate the critical components necessary for a penetration, joint, or perimeter fire containment system to achieve the intended firestop performance. They should not drift into becoming as-built drawings or full project coordination documents.

Keeping EJs focused protects their value, improves turnaround times, reduces unnecessary revisions, and helps ensure that these documents remain aligned with industry guidance.

Download the full IFC position statement to better understand the proper expectations for Engineering Judgment drawings and details.

Visit our Engineering Judgment resource page for guidance on all EJ’s.